Archive for the ‘Uncategorized’ Category

Cathedral and Bazaar: a UNESCO perspective

Tuesday, August 31st, 2010

UNESCO is unhappy with Georgian efforts to rebuild Bagrati Cathedral.

The ruins are “world heritage site”, and are supposed to stay that way.

The cathedral was sacked by the Mongols in 1265 and the Persians in 1615. It was rebuilt every time. Because it was needed as cathedral, not as a museum. There is something terribly wrong with conservation efforts that deny people the legacy in its original meaning. Apparently, for post-Christian Europe it is impossible to imagine that people choose a cathedral over the money which UNESCO is prepared to shovel for the right to keep this 6th century complex in ruins.

When does a civilization die? Maybe it happens when books become “antique” – not to be read but admired for their covers, when cathedrals become “museums”, when form prevails over the essence, when  chain of ages gets disrupted.

Shhhh… wanna buy some talent?

Saturday, August 14th, 2010

The reqruiterspeack made its way into boardrooms of the corporations. The talk about “talent acquisition” surreptitiously crept up over the last decade, and became de-facto standard for bundling together workers of all stripes. Whatever happened to skills and knowledge that used to be the market staple over last couple thousands years? What had  happened to the talent, genius, giants?

 Obviously, a devaluation had taken place. Talent used to be unique and mysterious, a combination of skills, knowledge and something not quite identifiable – but you know it when you see it… If you listen to the HR departments today they are all in business of “talent recruitment”, “talent retention”, “talent acquisition”.

How do you quantify talent?  Does this sound right to you: “I have thirty talents working for me”?

One fallacy which this perpetuates is the idea that “talents” are interchangeable. They are not. Talent is unique, a singularity unto itself, and it has to be treated like this.

Tell the Apple board that you’d like to replace Steve Jobs with another “talent” at 50% discount, or Mozart with a diligent graduate of a local conservatory, or Einstein with a hard-working fellow student from Eidgenössische Polytechnische Schule…

Another one is that talent can be taught. “Learn to think like Newton, and we’ll teach you how to think like Leibnitz for half-price!”

Maybe, this is the real reason that the innovation sputters in the USA?

Lost in translation: Language and Perception

Monday, July 26th, 2010

The idea of a language defining our perception was supposedly disproved by Noam Chomsky’s introduction of the “Universal Grammar”. And yet, this new study opens the very same can of worms again, along the Sapir- Whorf Hypothesis lines.

If Russian speakers could see more shades of blue because the have more words describing it, and Japanese and Spanish speakers struggle recalling agents of accidental events because of the way their respective languages work, maybe our ability to learn and understand semantically significant concepts is also influenced by the medium through which we absorb these concepts – a language in this case?

Maybe there was something to “the golden key” – Latin and Greek Languages, common languages of the European scholars - that kept link to antiquity in the darkness of Middle Ages? Maybe, there is language uniquely suited to learning some specific subject?  Domain Specific Languages are relatively common in computer programming; maybe the concept could be applied back to “natural” languages and comprehension?

A word of caution to the tale…

There is a short story by Robert Sheckley - ”The Language of Love” (1957, Notions: Unlimited); in it a young man sets out to learn the almost forgotten Language of Love, developed by the now extinct inhabitants of a distant planet. After maatering the language, he discovers the reason behind the extinction of that alien race – the Language of Love is so precise and complex that learning (and then using it) becomes an endeavor unto itself, impeding communications with uninitiated, and leaving no time for anything else… ;)

Sybase, an SAP company

Sunday, May 16th, 2010

SAP has acquired Sybase for about $6bln…I might  be missing something but it seems to be an act of desperation – on both sides –  all this talk about synergy and efficacy notwithstanding.

The way I see it, Sybase was floundering for years, first squandering their RDBMS position by neglecting markets (as witnessed by, for instance, in their pathetic TPC benchmarks and truly archaic dialect of Transact-SQL), then foregoing initial success of PowerBuilder ($3,000 for an IDE?! this what comes out of $1 billion dealin 1994 with PowerSoft) unable to compete with more nimble VisualBasic and Delphi (though not necessarily more technologically advanced) in the data access applications arena..

SAP was steamrolling businesses into what they defined as set of “best practices” until their Borg-like message  sunk in in the wake of high profile implementation failures, as well as increased competition from Oracle, Microsoft and others following of ERP market consolidation (Siebel, JD Edwards, Lawson).  Then there are number of departures from SAP management team (Leo Apotheker being the latest)…

What will happen of all suite of Sybase products, what will happen to dozens of overlapping competing technologies and solutions – is any body’s guess. I would stay away from SAP stock for awhile.

Losing browser wars

Wednesday, May 12th, 2010

Microsoft is losing browser wars on younger generation. The main culprit – it is slow. It is annoyingly slow to start up (what is it doing these minutes while opening on my computer? Connecting to Microsoft to log my session? Initializing umpteen+ plugins and components?), it is slow to render graphics, it behaves erratically with downloads… Wikipedia supplies some stats on browser usage out there: IE @53%, Firefox @31% and Google Chrome @8%.  It was almost 90% of the market for the Microsoft’s IE as recent as 2005…  A bit of anecdotal evidence : my 16 years old hates Internet Explorer for all the reasons listed above – and he grew up with IE using it exclusively up until last year (that’s 8+ years!) , ditching it for Chrome. “It does what I need, and it is sooo fast!”.

I believe that Microsoft became too preoccupied with today’s corporate suits losing the younger generation; after all, they are in business selling Office products. Of course, they are paying lip service with flops like Zune and occasional successes like XBox… but lacking Google’s razor sharp focus. After all, Gioogle is doing exactly what Microsoft did back at the beginning of the 1990s, when facing uphill battle against entrenched UNIX boxes with Windows 3.11 and languages like Visual Basic 3.0. These were FUN!

Microsoft is not fun anymore, it is a serious business. And this is the problem it will face in the future when today’s kids graduate into corporate boardrooms.

What intuition is made of?

Monday, February 1st, 2010

In his review of a book by Diego Rasskin-Gutman “Chess Metaphors: Artificial Intelligence and the Human Mind”, a former World Chess Champion Garry Kasparov  recalls his defeat by the Deep Blue computer in 1997  as losing to a machine  “systematically evaluating 200 million possible moves on the chess board per second and winning with brute number-crunching force” (as opposed to his “human creativity and intuition”.)

This dichotomy made me wonder – do we really know how our human creativity and intuition works? Could it be possible that somewhere on a deep subconscious level our brain performs these 200,000,000 possible “mecanical” permutations, and surfaces the one that we then proudly label as “human intuition”?

NB: This might go as far back as Hegel’s principle of transformation of quantity into quality (which, possibly independently, restates an essentially Buddhist paradigm postulated a millennium before )

Would you recommend programming as a career to your son?

Tuesday, January 19th, 2010

For me it is a bit of a rhetorical question – I am raising two sons who have no inclination to follow in dad’s footsteps (no surprise there – I did not want to be an electrician like my dad either, instead I went on to study physics and chemistry).

But here is an interesting blog pondering the issue, and offering a piece of advice on where the sweet spot might be,  Next-Gen Jobs by Jim Ericson

He believes that analytics and metadata would become the next big thing, and sound career choices fot the next generation.

I have my doubts; I still remember an advice from a book on VBX programming I’ve read in the beginning of 1990s: “learn C++ and Visual Basic and you do not have to worry about where the next meal would come from”. Well, good luck to all the programmers out there who followed it. Though it did seem like a good piece of advice at the time: VBX was not easy (arcane C/C++ code), and demand seemed to be inexhaustible (VBX controls allowed to break through limitations of Visual Basic, and yet have easy development environment to program Windows GUI)… Then OCX standard came, which morphed into OLE/COM( and later was supplanted by .Net model), and on top of that one could use VB to implement the spec – no need for additional programming language….

Now, one might argue that this was merely a technology while analytics is  a Profession….  Admittedly, there is something to it.  Still, I believe that specialties of the future are not spelled out yet, and the most promising ones are spanning more than one domain (there was a short SF story where career counselors were randomly matching specialties, and the student was supposed to figure out what the profession might actually be, e.g. “forensic linguistics” or “linguistic taxidermy” etc … ‘ don’t remember the author, might have been Robert Sheckley)

Who had ever heard about SEO professional before advent of Google?

Scarcity of will

Monday, January 11th, 2010

US elementary school teachers are pretty efficient when it comes to scaring kids out of their wits with predictions of doom and gloom… A ten years old cannot find Europe on the map, or do long division, or say what WWII was about, but he knows for sure that the world is doomed, that humans destroy the Earth, and it all will be gone by the time he grows up! Progress became a dirty word, science is barely tolerable, and most of the time represents the root of all evil – that’s it, when it not entertaining or focused on ecology… (and I am speaking from personal experience)

It is a wonder that some kids still find the will to wake up and face the doomed world another day!

As the saying has it: where there is a will there is a way.  If one to accept it as an axiom (and I do), then the logical conclusion would be that the world would run out of ways only when it runs out of will.

This “doom and gloom” culture constantly underestimates human ingenuity. William Stanley Jevons  in 1865 confidently predicted that the world will run out of coal within a generation; the latest reports tell us that we have more discovered deposits than ever.  Sheikh Yamani, former OPEC oil minister, hit the nail on the head when remarked: “The Stone Age didn’t end because we ran out of stones”…

Power tends to corrupt…

Monday, January 11th, 2010

Researcher exposes Google spyware connections

“According to Ben Edelman, an assistant professor at the Harvard Business School and a staunch anti-spyware advocate, Google is charging advertisers for what he described as “conversion-inflation” traffic from the WhenU spyware program.”

This might be a wake up call for some of anti-Microsoft crowd happily marching under Google liberation banner.

John Emerich Edward Dalberg Acton once famously remarked: “Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Great men are almost always bad men.” To paraphrase: “great companies are almost always bad companies”. This was true of Microsoft, Oracle, Sun, IBM – all of which used and abused their power in their respective heydays. Google will be (is?) no exception. As Bedouin saying has it: “trust in Allah, but tie your camel first”.

Flat Mars Society

Sunday, January 10th, 2010

Avatar  - the latest eye-candy from Hollywood my kids caused me to watch… Despite stunning imagery, the main message is of doubtful value: ignorance is bliss (by the same token, science and industrialization are evil). This is not unlike Gospel’s message “The meek shall inherit the Earth” (Matthew 5:5) which harkens back to Ecclesiastes’  ”For in much wisdom is much grief: and he that increaseth knowledge increaseth sorrow” (1:18, King James Bible), Rousseau’s theory of Natural Man…  The most recent elaboration could be found in Kurt Vonnegut’s novel Galapagos where all the sorrows of humankind are traced to ”the only true villain in … story: the oversized human brain”.

What is ironic that the same anti-intellectual message is being delivered with ever increasing scientific sophistication of the medium…

As Robert A. Heinlein once remarked (as I remember it):  “Establishment of Flat Mars Society would be surest proof that it became civilized”.